THE GREATEST DEBATE

Opinions are neither correct nor incorrect. They are simply ideas and feelings, and not substantiated as immutable facts. Differing opinions can lead to interesting debatable topics. These factors, techniques and methods should be considered when attempting to evaluate the greatest NHL hockey players:

• Statistics: An objective way to evaluate players is by contrasting their career statistics in goals, assists, points (plus/minus) and penalty minutes.
  
• Dominance in Era: Evaluations of a dominant player when compared to his contemporaries additionally is justified. One must clearly adjust his statistical merits based upon the prevalent style of play, the equipment, the rules of the NHL game during that period, and balance his performance when compared to his peers.
  
• Individual Awards and Achievements: Consideration of the number of individual awards a player has won, e.g. Hart Trophies (MVP), Art Ross Trophies (leading scorer) and Norris Trophies (best defenseman) are valid.
  
• Longevity and Consistency: Players who have maintained a high level of performance over a longer period of time are often more highly regarded. Consistently performing at an elite level throughout a career can be an indicator of greatness.
  
• Skill or Talent: Assessing the player's skill set, including skating, shooting, passing, defending, and his hockey IQ is required. A player's ability to excel in multiple areas of the game can contribute to their respect and admiration.
  
• Impact on the Game: Consideration of the player's impact on the game goes well beyond “on ice” performance. Did he change the way the game was played and were rules altered? Has he influenced future generations of players? Was his impact extended beyond the rink and did it resonate with fans and the general public.
  
• Versatility: How well-rounded was the player? Did he demonstrate superior skills in differing roles or situations? Versatility evidences a player's adaptability and genuine mastery of the game.
  
• Team Success and Achievements: Hockey is a team sport and a player's impact on his team's success needs to be considered. Players who have led their teams to Stanley Cup Championships or deep into the playoffs will be viewed more favorably.